Ned Rorem: The Nantucket Songs

NED ROREM

It doesn't seem so long ago - about fifteen years for the two cycles, twenty-five for the miscellaneous songs - that the ensuing program notes were penned, yet here I am at seventy, and the earliest work mentioned, Little Elegy, dates from 1948. But if perspective alters with the passage of time, viewpoint does not. I can remember like yesterday the actual sensation of writing Little El­egy, though I could not write it today (mainly because it's already written). I do envy the innocent knack for hitting the nail on the head without crushing my finger; but though youth can be imitated, it cannot be repeated. Thus, I feel re­warded for the present CRI reissue, a chance to hear again not only my own lost voice, but the voices of certain oth­ers who were inimitable singers, some of whom have stopped singing forever.

- Ned Rorem, Autumn 1993

From 1980:

The Elizabeth Sprague Coolidge Foundation commissioned me to write a group of songs, stipulating that I must be the pianist not only for their premiere but for an entire vocal program with an singer I wished, within reason. I asked for Phyllis Bryn-Julson, who (being rea­sonable) accepted. Thus with her talents continually in mind I withdrew to the island of Nantucket where, since 1974, I have owned a house, and where, between No­vember 1978 and May 1979, I completed The Nantucket Songs. A subtitle might be "Popular Songs," insofar as popular means entertaining rather than classi­cally indirect. Indeed, these songs -merry or complex or strange though their texts may seem - aim away from the head and toward the diaphragm. They are, as collegians say, emotional rather than intellectual, and need not be under­stood to be enjoyed.

The first rendition of The Nantucket Songs occurred in the Coolidge Auditorium of the Library of Congress, October 30, 1979. It was from a broadcast of that public concert that the present recording of the cycle was made.

Nothing a composer can say about his music is more pointed than the music itself. But here is a final thought: the performance of The Nantucket Songs,during which Phyllis Bryn-Julson and I, unbeknownst to each other, both had fevers of 102 degrees, is by definition live and unedited.

From 1969:

Every since as a teenager I started writing songs - short settings of qual­ity poems for single voice with piano accompaniment - I've been tempted by the flashy, thicker textures of trios and quintets and such. But either from sloth or shrewdness I never did anything about it. Off the opera stage these groupings were rare: the vocal ensemble not being a standard chamber medium, at least not in this century, there seemed little rea­son for composing one. Even the deli­cious duets of Mendelssohn and Schumann, or Brahms' unique Liebeslieder Waltzes were exceptions to their time and written more for fun than money. Community fun and amateur partici­pation have not been major preoccupa­tions of modern art (Christmas carols not­withstanding), and even the solo voice recital has verged on extinction. Lately, though, with the Beatles' advent - not to mention mixed-media happenings throughout the globe - there seems to be a reawakening of the musical pleasure principle and of group participation.

Even so, I would probably never have come to composing an ensemble were it not for a practical impetus. Some Trees is a trio designed for specific sing­ers on a specific occasion. The singers are those on this record. The occasion was a recital (Town Hall, December 12, 1968) in which each soloist separately performed a group of my songs. It seemed appropriate to end the concert by joining the artists in a group offering, and so I com­posed this cycle.

The words are by John Ashbery. I had never set his poetry before, although I had often used that of his friends Ken­neth Koch and the late Frank O'Hara with whom he forms the nucleus of The New York School of Poets (roughly my genera­tion), so-called, I guess, because of their championing of The New York School of painters. Each of them and all their younger entourage have written verse that appears ideal for madrigal combi­nations meant for the joy of collective unity in the modern home and hall.

Little Elegy was composed for, and first sung by, Nell Tangeman in 1948. Night Crow is from a group of eight settings of Theodore Roethke poems that were commissioned and first sung by Alice Esty in 1959. Look Down, Fair Moon is from a group of five Whitman settings, commissioned and first sung (to his own accompaniment on the virginal) by Wilder Burnap in 1957.

The Tulip Tree and What Sparks and Wiry Cries are settings of poetry by Paul Goodman who once was my Manhattan Goethe: the poet to whom I, as a balladeer, most frequently returned. From The Lordly Hudson in 1946, through The Poet's Requiem 1955, to Sun in1966, his verse, prose, and theater beautifully served my short tunes, choruses, and op­era. Lives shift, ever faster. We seldom meet anymore, in either speech or song. Paul today seems more drawn toward wisely guiding the political acts of men; this can't be done through poetry. And I grow more withdrawn. Yet while re-studying this music, all written in France during the early 1950s, I become rekindled with a need for the words and music of that easier decade. The rekindling may not fire more songs of the sort. It will, however, illuminate again a bit of con­versation between old friends.

The poem For Poulenc was written by Frank O'Hara expressly to be set by me on a commission from Alice Esty who first performed it on a Poulenc Memorial Re­cital in 1963. The piano music beneath the first two lines of the final stanza is quoted form the Ave Maria in "Dialogues Des Carmelites."

From 1980:

In the autumn of 1975 I noted in my journal: "I am composing a cycle of songs for soprano Joyce Mathis [Women's Voices], of whom a not inconspicuous feature, at least to me since I am white, is that she's black. I have chosen to musicalize poems only by women (I men­tion this now, and never again, since the main point of the poems is that they're good), but none of these women is black. For my music there are no apt black female poets, since they mostly deal with the black condition. Can I identify from

inside with blackness as I can with femaleness? None of my ancestors were Negro slaves, though half of them were women. Artists contain all sexes but not all races. Still, years ago when I was composing Ariel, maybe Robin Morgan's harsh words were true: "Leave Plath to our sisters, stick to men poets." If I feel no more need for Plath it's precisely be­cause she was a woman, and I am not, not even metaphorically... Not that a com­poser need feel,or even respect, a poem in order to set it well. And some great poems that thrill are more impossible to musicalize than lesser ones that merely ring a bell. The question of which com­posers select which poets to set to music, and how they set them, is endlessly en­grossing. A woman's setting of women's poetry might not be better than mine but will be different, not only because she's another person but because she's female. How to prove that difference? Is there more disparity between a man and a woman than between one good composer and another good composer? It's hard to deal with a woman's poem insofar as that poem dwells on solely womanly problems. Yet I'm writing a cycle on woman's poems. From Antigone to Phaedre, through the Marschallin to Blanche DuBois, great-women roles have been written by men. But in plays and in opera these roles have been part of a larger pattern - a pattern, however ec­centric, that we all grow up with. Could a man write a solo lyric poem, as a woman, and make it tell?"

When Joyce Mathis asked me ear­lier that summer to composer a cycle for her, it had been twelve years since any­one had commissioned songs from me. (War Scenes in 1969 was conceived as a gift for Gerard Souzay.) So much for my reputation as a major song composer. The eleven poems -probing women's anger, love, joy, and anguish over five centuries, were accordingly presented by Mathis in Alice Tully Hall on November 4, 1976, with pianist Warren Wilson.

Unlike the live recording of The Nantucket Songs,the recording of Women's Voices results from dozens of takes made in an empty church where Katherine Ciesinski and I, and the page turner (the composer Charles Turner, ap­propriately), all enjoying good health and nibbled apricots while listening to playbacks.

NED ROREM is one of the nation's most widely performed composers. As this disc is released, he celebrates his seventieth birthday year. Rorem, who has composed over three hundred songs, is no less accomplished in instrumental writing. He won the Pulitzer Prize in 1976 for his orchestral suite Air Music. Other honors include Guggenheim fellowships and awards from the American Academy of Arts & Letters, of which he is now a member. Recent works include the Con­certo for Piano Left-Hand, written for Gary Graffman and premiered by the or­chestra of the composer's alma mater, The Curtis Institute; and an English Horn Concerto for the New York Philharmonic. Rorem has also published twelve books. In 1994, Simon and Schuster will bring out a memoir, Knowing When to Stop.

From CRI SD 238:

Little Elegy published by Hargail Music, Inc.; Night Crow published by Henman Press, Inc.; The Tulip and For Poulenc published by E.G. Schirmer; Look Down Fair Moon, What Sparks and Wiry Cries and Some Trees published by Boosey & Hawkes Inc., (ASCAP)

Producer: Carter Harmon.

Recording Engineer: Jerry Newman at Stereo Sound Studio, NYC in January 1969.

The original recordings were made possible by an annual award of the American Academy of Arts & Letters.

From CRI SD 485:

Women's Voices produced by Carolyn Sachs.

Recording Engineer: David Hancock.

Recorded in New York City in June of 1982.

THE NANTUCKET SONGS produced by Carter Harmon and recorded by The Library of Congress in October 1979 (ASCAP). Published by Boosey & Hawkes Inc. The original recordings were made possible through the generous support of Mrs. Norton Baum, Morris Golde, Mr. and Mrs. Ernest Heller, Mrs. Fred Plant, Joseph Machlis, and private individuals.

Funding for this compact disc was provided through the generous support of The Aaron Copland Fund for Music, and through private individuals.